Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tracey Hay's avatar

Yes, yes, yes, Charles. It’s all hollowing out. I feel that really acutely in contemplating what iChristmas is all about for my son, aged seven. He sees right through all of the trappings, thankfully. And what he expects, almost demands of me, is for something more sacred. Something divine and real. He has mostly enjoyed our small rituals, our offerings to nature and community. He has been especially interested in giving and being in service, rather than receiving. In fact he is quite bewildered by the gifts he receives. He has wholeheartedly confirmed to me what I’ve felt and known all along, this is all crumbling - the consumerist idea of Christmas - I’ve been keenly aware of that since my childhood. And now I see it.

All of my inherited celebrations seem hollow, I’m rebuilding something from the ashes. I’ve been picking around in the debris for a while. Even New Year seems meaningless, although I’ve been contemplating on the old traditions of new year : cleaning your house out of all the clutter and unnecessary baggage, welcoming in community, and in Scotland making sure the1st ‘footer’ (1st person to enter your home in the New Year) brings symbols of abundance and health. We can also learn from the old rituals, they hold meaning.

I’m glad to hear the young adults are seeing through the veneer and the tinsel. And that you bring this to light.

Thank you for these reflections, as usual I resonate with your thoughts and I’m grateful for your ability to convey them in a lovely way 🙏🙏

Expand full comment
Margaret Anna Alice's avatar

What a gorgeous way to usher in the new year, Charles. Reminds me of one of my favorite pieces by you:

• “Time to Push” (https://charleseisenstein.substack.com/p/time-to-push)

I know you have nuanced views on forgiveness, amnesty, and justice as well as the role (or lack thereof) of planning in the crimes against humanity that have been committed in the name of COVID. I would be curious to hear your thoughts on the poem I just published:

• “Mistakes Were NOT Made: An Anthem for Justice” (https://margaretannaalice.substack.com/p/mistakes-were-not-made-an-anthem)

It appears to have struck a chord with many readers, who resonate with the call for accountability.

Expand full comment
144 more comments...

No posts